As Sarah Palin winked, wiggled, and gee-whizzed her way through the debate last night, a number of women were gathering together in homes all over Alaska to watch the debate and prepare their next steps. Already in the last month they’ve come together to organize major marches, petitions, and thousands of female voices to speak out against Palin.
The women against Palin movement in Alaska has grown beyond grassroots. In fact, up until McCain chose Palin as a running mate a few weeks ago, it was small and distant and barely a seed. But since then, vociferous female bloggers in Alaska helped organize an anti-Palin rally in mid-September that included around 1,000 mostly female Palin opponents carrying signs like “Palin does not speak for me.” It was the biggest political rally the state has ever seen.
And just last week those same women helped organize an online petition to demand the removal of Alaska Attorney General Talis Colberg, who is accused of continually obstructing the ongoing Troopergate investigation being conducted by the Alaska Legislative Council. Why are they suddenly gathering en masse to deliver a message? They want the rest of America to know that, not only is Palin skilled in the art of mollifying and winking, she’s adroit at hoodwinking, too.
Maia Nolan, an Alaskan who blogs at OwnTheSidewalk.com, says she resents the McCain campaign exploiting Palin in an effort to collect disgruntled Hillary Clinton voters. Nolan, who supported Clinton, says the strategy was a s*xist move, and not only does she not intend to support McCain and Palin, she says the public outside of Alaska is woefully misinformed about McCain’s VP pick.
“There seems to be this idea out there that she’s an Alaskan folk hero, with her 80 percent approval rating and her Iron Dog champion husband,” Nolan tells MnIndy. “People may not realize that she came into office with a 90 percent approval rating on day one. Why? She’s not [former governor] Frank Murkowski. All she had to do to be popular was show up and not buy another jet. Not only did she not buy another jet,” Nolan says, “she tacked an extra $1200 onto everyone’s Permanent Fund Dividend check — the amount of which was announced right around the time that last pre-VP poll was taken. Of course she was popular.”
But, Nolan adds, Palin’s Dividend Checks and slash on taxes have hurt smaller outstate regions who aren’t so generous with their support. “She may not be so popular in places like Adak,” Nolan says, “a remote Aleutian village whose residents have been notified they need to leave before winter comes because the town can no longer afford fuel for heat and power.”
Equal rights?
A woman who goes only by the name of AK Muckraker and blogs at Mudflats agrees that the public is being deceived about Palin, and adds that words like “equal rights” falling out of her mouth are just as ill-conceived and meaningless as the rest of her word stews. It’s for those reasons she blogs nearly every day about the issues, and hopes women everywhere are listening.
“I think that the public automatically assumes since she is a woman and a mother that she is pro-woman and pro-family,” AK Muckraker tells me. “They need to understand that while Palin may describe herself in these terms, her own definition of these terms falls far out of mainstream American views. The fact that N.O.W., which hasn’t endorsed any presidential ticket since Mondale-Ferraro, has endorsed Obama-Biden, speaks volumes.”
Blogger Linda Kellen Biegel Linda Kellen Biegel, who blogs at Blue Oasis, says the misconception of Palin as any kind of champion of woman’s rights is one of the scariest and most dangerous. “She is a woman yet there is no evidence that she supports issues that are important to women… quite the opposite,” Biegel says. “She doesn’t support equal pay for equal work. As the Mayor of Wasilla she cut the budget so that rape victims had to pay for their own forensic exams [rape kits] and refused to change that until then-Governor Knowles signed a law that demanded the city pay for them. There are over 900 families of children with disabilities who are on a waiting list for services, when Alaska’s $5 billion surplus sits in the bank.”
Biegel notes it would cost $45 million of the $5 billion surplus in the sixth-wealthiest state in the country to cover these families. She and other Alaskan bloggers say Palin’s record has consistently been anti-family and anti-women.
The great debate
So how’d she do last night? Just hours before the debate, Nolan had a prediction. “I expect that Palin, lacking the experience and expertise Sen. Biden brings to the debate, will resort to cheap shots and campaign-crafted sound bites. I don’t expect her to actually debate the issues. She didn’t know much about the issues when she ran for governor in 2006, and she actually made that work for her in the debates by making her better-prepared, more knowledgeable opponents seem like bean counters who were out of touch with what the people of Alaska really wanted.” She couldn’t have been more right if she had posed the question to Palin’s talkative God.
Indeed, some pundits were left shocked at Palin’s performance last night. She cheerled for the GOP ticket and delivered her talking points as if she were at a rally instead of a debate. She skirted questions and reiterated key words and phrases. She made Biden appear like he focused too much on minituae and, in some cases, moderator Gwen Ifill. While Palin constantly looked at the camera—the “people”–Biden erred, perhaps, by focusing on the moderator and on numbers and policies.
By any reasonable calculus, Palin actually had the advantage going in. The bar had been lowered after a series of interviews. She had no Washington record to defend herself against. And with many softball questions, she never had to discuss McCain’s real record and could instead refer to him as a concept. In a sense, she did what the right often criticizes Obama for doing: She chose style over substance.
Blogger and radio host Shannyn Moore But for some Alaskan women, Palin’s small town librarian performance was exactly what they expected. Blogger and Air America radio host Shannyn Moore says she wasn’t surprised at all by Palin’s folksy production. “She did what I thought she’d do,” Moore says. “She didn’t answer questions. She talked around questions and avoided specifics. And she was a bit snarky, winked, and had some sort of accent no Alaskan I know has. The bar was lowered and she went over it.”
AK Muckraker was actually a bit surprised by the new winky Palin, but not her talking points. Muckraker says Palin has used the same strategy of avoiding questions during her short time as governor of Alaska. “I was turned off by her winking and nose crinkling and cutesy, folksy answers,” she says. “My perception of her performance is that she was well prepared with a series of talking points. She chose whichever one fit closest with the question, and if she didn’t have one, she used the energy talking point for good measure. I thought she did better than most people were expecting, but that after sifting through the ‘blizzard of words’ it was obvious that she didn’t really answer the questions, nor was there much substance to what she said.”
Very interesting comments coming from her fellow Alaskans. I think it speaks volumes about what these women think of her governing. If your own residents can't cheer you on then something is definitely 'Rotten in Denmark'.
Monday, October 6th 2008 at 9:12PM
Jen Fad
Thanks for the links and I am telling you they are very informative. S. Palin is so shallow. Why does she take credit for things and not give credit to the people who work hard to do the work? This is not a good quality for a leader.
Monday, October 6th 2008 at 9:19PM
Jen Fad
